Questions of the application and interpretation of the ne bis in idem principle in eu law continue to surface in the case law of different european courts. The ne bis in idem principle in the interpretation of european courts. European court of justice rules ne bis in idem principle may. This principle was also addressed in the case law of the european court of human. Simultaneous application of eu and national competition law by the same competition authority. Ne bis in idem in eu law 2016, hardcover for sale online. The court found that this legislation does not infringe eu law, both because of the importance of res judicata to eu law and because where there is an acquittal in a criminal case, bringing an administrative procedure infringes the ne bis in idem principle. Non bis in idem, which translates literally from latin as not twice against the same thing, is a legal doctrine to the effect that no legal action can be instituted twice for the same cause of action. The ne bis in idem principle in eu law wolters kluwer. It is also anchored in various international instruments see below paras 512. Google the jury is still out at least in the eu dg comps settlement procedure evaluated in timab industries. The icc jurisdiction is complementary to national law, and article 20 of the rome statute specifies that even if the principle remains in general terms, it. Non bis in idem, which translates literally from latin as not twice against the same thing, is a legal doctrine to the effect that no legal action can be instituted twice for.
Ne bis in idem in eu law books pics download new books. Email your librarian or administrator to recommend adding this book to your organisations collection. Taking as a starting point the rationale and content of ne bis in idem as a principle of national criminal law, the rules for its transnational application shall be examined. European union cjeu regarding the ne bis in idem principle in criminal matters, and explains how this case law has helped shaping the scope and main features of the ne bis in idem principle in the eu legal order. Ne bis in idem in the case law of the european court of justice daniel sarmiento. European union cjeu regarding the ne bis in idem principle in criminal matters, and explains how this case law has helped shaping the.
Ne bis in idem in eu law edited by bas van bockel november 2016. Sauer clearly stated in his textbook on procedural law that ne bis in idem. Eriksson, veronica lu jurm02 201 department of law. The ne bis in idem principle in eu law leiden repository. Ne bis in idem in eu law 2016, hardcover for sale online ebay. The principle of ne bis in idem in international law. This book explores the principle, and the way the court of justice of the european union has interpreted it, in the context of competition law and the areas of freedom, security and justice, human rights law and tax law read more. It is aimed at providing guidance in the application of the ne bis in idem. Pdf ne bis in idem in international law researchgate. Some upcoming decisions of the cjeu on the ne bis in idem. The development of the ne bis in idem principle in the eu legal order illustrates the. According to wellestablished case law of the court of justice of the european union, the ne bis in idem principle does not require the judgment of a court, but may also be triggered by the decision of a public prosecutor e. Unlike the principle of guilt, the european principle of ne bis in idem has seen.
It is a legal concept originating in roman civil law, but it is essentially the equivalent of the double jeopardy autrefois acquit doctrine found in common law jurisdictions. Abstract ne bis in idem is an evolving and current topic of eu law where recent case law has affected its application. Nov 15, 2017 however, on the other hand, the same article states that eu law can provide more extensive protection. The european law blog aims to highlight, and comment on, current developments in eu case law and legislation.
Ne bis in idem the charter and echr, possible affects of. This might push the court of justice of the european union to correct its position. So, member states must, when they are constructing sanctions in order to carry out rules in eu directives, keep themselves within the rules of the charter, i. The enhanced value of the human rights within the eu law through the charter and the principle of ne bis in idem. The ne bis in idem principle in eu law wolters kluwer legal. European jurisdictional conflicts transfer of proceedings.
It holds that eu law still does not provide a full foundation to both principles of criminal substantive law. Transposed to the field of competition law, the european court of justice stated that. The primary purpose of this book is to provide guidance and to address important issues in connection with the ne bis in idem principle in. European union eu law is increasingly influencing the substantive criminal. In this article i will concentrate on the ne bis in idem rules which exist within the frameworks of the european union and the council of europe in order to verify.
The primary purpose of this book is to provide guidance and to address important issues in connection with the ne bis in idem principle in eu law. Eu protection of the substantive criminal law principles of guilt and. Here, the court held that bringing both such proceedings exceeds what is necessary to. The ne bis in idem dialogue between the cjeu and the ecthr. The purpose of this study is to further clarify the substance, scope and interpretation of ne bis in idem as a single, autonomous principle within the legal order of the eu, by way of a. This development results in the prohibition under article 54 cisa being more sensitively triggerable, thus. Ne bis in idem in eu law by bas van bockel, hardcover. Rules on the application of ne bis in idem in the eu eclan. Arising from the work of two wellattended seminars, this new volume concentrates on highly topical issues in european law current problems in the enforcement of human rights in europe and the accession of the eu to the european convention on human rights. No part of this book may be reproduced in any form, by print, photoprint, microfilm or any other. Ne bis in idem the charter and echr, possible affects of the latest interpretation by the ecj of the ne bis in idem principle in the haparanda case.
To date, the thrust of opinion among writers denies that the principle of ne bis in idem can be recognized either as a rule of custom or a general principle of international law. The ne bis in idem principle is laid down in article 50 of the charter of. The legal principle of ne bis in idem restricts the possibility of a defendant being prosecuted repeatedly on the basis of the same offence, act, or facts. Finally, she considers whether the presumption of equivalent protection of the ecthr in favour of the eu is still justified. Ne bis in idem issues under the single supervisory mechanism bas van bockel. Pdf the transnational ne bis in idem principle in the eu. The principle of ne bis in idem in criminal matters in the. Ne bis in idem in tax offences in eu law and echr law peter wattel. The author identifies and describes obstacles that stand in the way of a single, autonomous, and uniformly applicable general ne bis in idem principle of eu law differently worded provisions within the different european frameworks. The principle of ne bis in idem and the application of criminal. Recent developments in the jurisprudence of both the court of justice of the european union cjeu and the european court of human rights ecthr have demonstrated how international tribunals can collaboratively act to develop the international law principle of ne bis in idem to increase its clout. The article focuses on two fundamental rights that rule substantive criminal law.
As the first contribution to an indepth understanding of the fundamental problems and issues associated with the interpretation and application of a european ne bis in idem principle, this study takes a giant step towards developing and refining the principle within the legal order of the eu. Mirror download for the ne bis in idem principle in eu law. Ne bis in idem in eu law edited by bas van bockel november 2016 skip to main content accessibility help we use cookies to distinguish you from other users and to provide you with a better experience on our websites. Buy ne bis in idem in eu law, by bas van bockel, isbn 9781107451841, published by cambridge university press from. Two simultaneous fines for the same competition law infringement. The case law of the european court of justice on the ne bis in idem principle.
No part of this book may be reproduced in any form, by print, photoprint, microfilm or any. Ne bis in idem in eu law lund university publications. Ne bis in idem in eu law bas van bockel this study, written by distinguished scholars in their respective fields, addresses the application and interpretation of the ne bis in idem principle in eu law. This book explores the principle, and the way the court of justice of the european union has interpreted it, in the context of competition law and the areas of freedom, security and justice, human rights law and tax law. Case c61717, powszechny zaklad ubezpieczen na zycie, eu.
The recognition of ne bis in idem as a supranational right. Simultaneous application of eu and national competition law. The general principles of eu law remain one of the most complex areas of eu law. However, on the other hand, the same article states that eu law can provide. Ne bis in idem in international law by gerard conway ssrn. Apr 30, 2018 on march 20, 2018, the grand chamber of the court of justice of the european union ruled that that the ne bis in idem principle, an individuals right not be prosecuted or punished twice for the same offense, may be restricted in order to protect eu financial interests and markets. The ne bis in idem as a general principle of eu law. Ne bis in idem a response for the bar council of england.
General principles of eu law oxford european union law. The principle of ne bis in idem, laid down in article 4 of protocol 7 to the european convention on human rights and in article 50 of the charter of fundamental rights of the european union, is the european equivalent of the double jeopardy clause in the united states. Sarmiento, ne bis in idem in the case law of the european court of justice, in van bockel 2016, supra n. The ne bis in idem principle is a litmus test of fundamental rights protection in the eu. Conceptual jurisprudential, by bas van bockel, isbn 97890411560, published by kluwer law international from. The ne bis in idem principle is laid down in article 50 of the charter of fundamental rights of the european union. The ne bis in idem as a general principle of eu law pursuant to article 63 of the treaty on european union hereafter, the teu in the wording given by the treaty of lisbon signed on the of. The ne bis in idem principle in proceedings related to anti. Sep 26, 20 in posing these questions, this article asks whether a legal person can derive a right to transnational protection in the area of freedom, security and justice from the different sources of ne bis in idem obligations in domestic law, in public international law human rights law and mutual legal assistance and in eu law. Bar council of england and wales ne bis in idem a response rudi fortson 4 29th march 2006 and ne bis in idem, should be approached holistically rather than in a piecemeal way. Afterwards, she examines the equivalency of the human rights protection provided by the ecj in light of the minimum standards of the echr in three specific fields naming law, ne bis in idem and equality of arms.
Buy ne bis in idem in eu law by bas van bockel with free. European court of justice rules ne bis in idem principle. The ne bis in idem principle in proceedings related to. European court of human rights ruling in the case zolotukhin vs russia have had a. This paper deals with the application of the principle of ne bis in idem in ec antitrust enforcement. Evolution of european criminal procedure law ne bis in idem principle guarantees under the european convention of human rights principles of international criminal law procedures and substantive law of the international criminal court icc praise for the first edition. They can be found not least in the main sources of human rights of the eu legal order. The case law of the european court of human rights on the ne bis in idem principle in article 4 of protocol 7 echr. To begin, it is important to bear in mind that both the echr art.
Transnational law enforcement and the ne bis in idem. Meanwhile the eu, since the coming into force of the treaty of amsterdam, has been. Get free shipping on ne bis in idem in eu law by bas van bockel, from. Therefore, what in effect was being achieved by the cjeu in m was the integration of ne bis in idem norms between two discrete jurisdictions at least as far as article 54 cisa read with article 50 of the charter applies in eu law. Penalties in tax law in light of the principle ne bis in idem. The ne bis in idem principle in the legal order of the eu. Transposed to the field of competition law, the european court of justice. The present article focuses on the ne bis in idem principle in the context of an area of freedom, security and justice. The purpose of this study is to further clarify the substance, scope and interpretation of ne bis in idem as a single, autonomous principle within the legal order of the eu, by way of a conceptual and jurisprudential analysis.
Their extrapolation and application by the court of justice raises profound questions about the values of the eu, the rights of individuals, the interaction between eu and national law, and the role of the judiciary in shaping eu law. This book explores the principle, and the way the court of. It is submitted in this contribution that article 50 cfr is indeed applicable to all punitive sanctions, regardless of whether the case involved administrative or criminal law, or application in a national or transnational context transnational law enforcement in the european union and the ne bis in idem. The ne bis in idem principle in eu law bas van bockel. The principle of ne bis in idem in criminal matters in the case law. This is volume 6 in the series swedish studies in european law. The principle of ne bis in idem in ec antitrust enforcement. Jul 18, 2008 to date, the thrust of opinion among writers denies that the principle of ne bis in idem can be recognized either as a rule of custom or a general principle of international law. Simultaneous application of eu and national competition. It is aimed at providing guidance in the application of the ne bis in idem principle in a transnational context. The ne bis in idem principle in eu law books express. The author identifies and describes obstacles that stand in the way of a single, autonomous, and uniformly applicable general ne bis in idem principle of eu law differently worded. However, on the other hand, the same article states that eu law can provide more extensive protection.
A textbook of roman law from augustus to justinian 3 ed. The ne bis in idem has been developed in eu law from a domestic into a transnational fundamental right and represents a truly european added value in comparison to international law. No one shall be liable to be tried or punished again in criminal proceedings for an offence for which he or she has already been finally acquitted or convicted within the union in accordance with the law. The paper outlines the concept of penalties in tax law and the fundamental notions and terms, and focuses on the ne bis in idem principle in respect to the coexistence coapplication of the tax. No person shall be tried before a national court for acts constituting serious violations of international humanitarian law under the present statute, for which he or she has already been tried by the international tribunal.
This book analyses these important implications, fulfilling a genuine need to assess the need for and the prospects of a european ne bis in idem principle. The rome statute establishing the international criminal court icc states that the non bis in idem principle has a peculiar meaning, especially in comparison to european supranational law. This phrase signifies that no one shall be twice tried for the same offence. Download for free the ne bis in idem principle in eu law pdf ebooks only at protectourcoastline. Eu protection of the substantive criminal law principles of. Human rights protection by the ecthr and the ecj a. The idem issue norel neagu abstract two major events occurred in the recent years have triggered a series of cases in the field of criminal law, having transnational dimension and requiring an identical interpretation of the. Our posts are short comments on judgments and legislation and are intended for anyone who wishes to stay informed on eu law.
727 1257 120 675 281 1 1324 594 806 497 764 1253 499 1037 149 937 1252 207 853 1025 413 128 62 1452 1191 1124 86 780 853 58 953 321 426 1357 186 1165 12 15 969 278 486